I am very much amazed with the way you see things about the movie and the way you tell them.Just wanted to say thank you. But the worst plot hole is that nobody figured out that the clothes which were found in Taylors possession were not worn by the girls at the time of their abduction. One of these underground people tells a shocked family, Were Americans. After that information, the title, Us, can be read as US, or U.S., or United States. And how could he know where the girls lived in the first place? If you want to get the full picture of the story, you have to unite the fragments. You want that for her? I dont buy it. The first kid they ever took was Alex in 1987, who was actually Barry Milland. In the Bible the snake is definitely associated with temptation. Michael Rafferty: The killer who wouldn't break | TheSpec.com Or Barry. I also think that Loki foreshadowing his abuse and imprisonment and the boys school that the father ran is another situation that contributes to the prisoners idea. We know its coming from Keller Dover, trapped underground. I think the layman tends to miss out on the motifs but grasps the plot. Keller would definitely not have charges pressed. These factors lead me to believe that the two girls, especially Anna, are potential abusers-to-be, because of their limited speech, the abuse they suffered, and the nature of inevitable violence in the cyclical maze, where abuse encourages more abuse. My question is who is the person that Joy sees in her flashback? Prisoners (2013) Full Cast & Crew See agents for this cast & crew on IMDbPro Directed by Denis Villeneuve Writing Credits Aaron Guzikowski . A theme in the Star Wars universe is that good is associated with light and bad is associated with darkness. The Mazes in Prisoners, Explained - movieweb.com One question that bugs me if Alex took the 2 girls in the RV, how comes the forensic team didnt find any trace of them? The man who pleaded guilty to murdering 10-year-old Holly Jones at a Toronto court Thursday morning fulfilled his "dark secret" when he abducted, sexually assaulted, and dismembered her shortly. Plus, excellent point that they wouldnt just jump to Oh! What follows are the vital details of Prisonersstudied, analyzed, deconstructed, dissected, unraveled, and presented for your review. After being detained, Michael Briere, 35, was charged with her murder. What is the connection between the snakes and girls clothes as well as the gaze in the boxes of the home of Taylor. Thank you! And they may not have had anything to go on. The Cinemaholic - Facebook Holly Jones Prisoners Quotes & Sayings Enjoy reading and share 6 famous quotes about Holly Jones Prisoners with everyone. Official Sites Alex Jones also refers to a maze. Hi Lory! Hundreds of Oklahoma inmates released in the largest commutation - CNN Prisoners, like Inception, ends on a cliffhanger. And how do we make sense of the miracles in our lives? So while Alex not confessing what happened to Keller could seem crazy, its in-line with how Prisoners shows other victims of abduction struggling to express themselves. Which would therefore create a maze of the mind and memories. I like your explanation of why Keller was probably saved but when I watched, I assumed he wasnt because he slid down too far and lost. But he is stuck in that child-like mentality and he did know what was going to happen to those kids, like he did with so many others. But IMO the explanations for Taylors weird actions do not hold together upon close scrutiny. The s**cide of Dover Sr definitely is the reason why Keller doesnt want to renovate his childhood home and adds another layer to that house where Alex is eventually imprisoned. According to WHNT-TV, 37-year-old Holly Debord pleaded guilty in July to the charges stemming from an incident in 2020. Her back was turned to him. Your basically kidnapping/torturing someone who is going to kill your daughter if they are released. Bob Taylor didnt have the opportunity. Thats the only way he can communicate to Loki where the girls might be, what happened to him, etc. In that time he created a body of work that changed popular music forever and influenced almost every great rock and roll artist to follow him. It serves a meta-purpose to make us aware of how to watch/understand the movie. Ive never read such a detailed and thorough review of a movie (well aside from LOTR-but that has a whole cult following). It was probably a promotional piece to go with the book because it doesnt look homemade. Reading what you wrote got me thinking if there is another layer to the way the trees relate to Kellers profession as a carpenter. Largest Database of Taylor County Mugshots. Will never see the world again. Thank you so much! Maybe all of this is in reference to him being the best detective they have and always is able to close the case. Alex is taken into custody, but is quickly released due to his IQ being the same as a ten year old. It comes from that which is inside of all is. So the priest left the man tied up to die. And even if all four parents were confused when they looked at the items which is highly unlikely the investigators should have noticed that according to the parents the items in Taylors possession were not worn by the girls on the day of their abduction. There are SO many other examples of this in the film! And now he kind of re-creates this moment. Keep in mind, the final scene was foreshadowed earlier in Prisoners. 2.) Also isnt the name Keller, too close to killer? And a criminal to boot. Hey Craig! It could provide some backstory about Keller but theres nothing concrete enough (at least as far as Im aware) that you could really point to. Anyway thanks for the insight. Actually, now that I think about it, it is possible that Holly was in fact trying to kill Anna by administering a lethal dose of opiates in that scene, since she would have realized by that point that she was at high risk of being caught by other parties. They see hes down there. And yeah, Ralph is definitely a prisoner. Thank you! State Prisons - MS We then get the final showdown that involves Kellers imprisonment and Lokis heroics. It happened in broad daylight, in the Junction Triangle neighbourhood in west Toronto, and detectives would. It is an experience that invites us to peel off the layers and try to make meaning from its moving images. She brings him to a hole underneath a car, forcing him in, shooting him in the leg and leaving him there. Psychological imprisonment: Alex and Bob Taylor both suffer from the trauma of their kidnapping. A character who wears a Masonic ring. Briere pleads guilty to Holly Jones's murder - The Globe and Mail As a carpenter, Keller is someone who destroys nature (trees) and uses the wood to build new things. A maze without an exit. And what if he does! Hundreds of Oklahoma inmates left prison Monday before their original sentences were over. What happens next Holly eventually describes as, Making children disappear is the war we wage with God. Just one question: how come the parents recognised their daughters clothes at the police station but didnt realise that they were not the ones the girls wore when they disappeared? And the long-dead Mr. Jones with the still-alive Keller Dover. Loki didnt find Keller torturing Alex. At one point her husband confessed his crimes to a local priest, out of a narcissistic boldness of feeling unable to get caught. | Loki is on team giant and kills the god Heimdall. Its a solid theory. They took Bob Taylor a few years later and he escaped after three weeks; Holly forgot all about him until reading the newspaper recently. I like your version of Loki saving him from hell of his own making but in spite of wonderful reasoning by Loki, what would have happened had Keller not listened to Alex when he was released and then not imprisoned and tortured him until he said they are in the maze? The abusers can only shake their fist at God so long as they assume that all the parents they abduct the children from will have the same re-action to their loss as they did. Holly likely assumed that Joy had been able to provide enough information to reveal her location. The Central Mississippi Correctional Facility (CMCF) was established in 1986 and built on 171 acres in Pearl in Rankin County. One detail I noticed that adds to the religious motif is that Loki is actually his last name and his first name is David that we see at the end of the film in the newspaper article Barry Milland AKA Alex Jones is reunited with family after 26 year. Before you trash this post, and think Im a nut case, please view the first 5 minuets of my video. Keller soon realizes that Holly was the real kidnapper. Kind of similar to the movie Zodiac. Happy to hear that Ayman! Hi, Chirs. There you have it. It is the key that ties the entire movie together. I got the dvd from my local library by chance and watched it and before I did I checked, it got 8.1 score. But if the kid WAS named Alex, I think Barry/Alex is saying that when he was a kid, the Joneses lured him to their house by asking if Barry wanted to play with their son. Its likely that since the girls probably went from the van to the hole that the scent wasnt lingering in a way the dogs would notice. Alex may have become too attached to Holly and the only home he had known for many years. Watching the movie for the first time, I noticed that Loki was also non-communicative at times, especially around the parents. And on his neck, a star that probably represents some other non-Christian religion. Theres a second Alex in Prisoners. Hopefully youre thinking, Thats an in-road!. The book was originally a work of fiction (I think there is something said about the book not making sense or being nonsense. But his instinct, thoroughness, and curiosity get the better of him. Joy and Anna leave the Birchs to find Annas missing whistle. The seemingly simple progress of the story is an artistic choice to create the sense of an itch you cant quite scratch, that theres more going on than you may have realized. Did Hollys husband have more dirt on the priest that could have gotten him in more trouble? The final song on the album is called Duckworth. But I can see that the parents were in so much shock that they wouldnt remember what the girls were wearing when they were taken. Experienced Human Resources professional with a Law Degree focused on Labor & Employment Law coursework. Rest In Peace Holly. Yeah, holding back the last part of the prayer is a huge moment. So he went to speak with Alexs mom (Barrys mom). Prisoners Ending, Explained - The Cinemaholic If you consider the lessons a child would learn, being taken, taught to never speak up, an abandonment of all hope & good in the world. But 5 years ago, he was missing. After being released from prison in 2012, Ms. Deane-Jones was given a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder and is now employed as an Uber driver. The overall rate of having been a victim was 35% for perpetrators and 11% for non-perpetrators. ), assistant property master (as Beth Morris), art department production assistant (as Steven 'Denver' Tolbert), art graphics (uncredited) / storyboard artist (uncredited), storyboard artist (uncredited) / visual consultant (uncredited), additional re-recording mixer (as Matthew Ladarola), additional production sound mixer (uncredited), adr recording engineer (uncredited) / adr recordist (uncredited), special effects technician (as Edward S. Backus), special effects technician (as Nick Coleman), special effects technician (as Michael Dzenowagis), special effects foreman (as Jeffrey D. Knott), special effects technician (as Randy Moore), 2d supervisor: Luma Pictures (as Alexandre Cancado), model artist: Luma Pictures / texture artist: Luma Pictures, paint artist: Luma Pictures / roto artist: Luma Pictures, matchmove artist: Luma Pictures / tracking artist: Luma Pictures, visual efffects supervisor: Pacific Title & Art Studio (as Phil Feiner), compositor: Luma Pictures (as Tim Fleur) / lighter: Luma Pictures (as Tim Fleur), compositor: Luma Pictures / lighter: Luma Pictures, lead paint: Luma Pictures (as Jessica Bakke) / lead roto: Luma Pictures (as Jessica Bakke), visual effects producer: Pacific Title & Art Studio (as Darin Millett), jr. compositor: Luma Pictures (as Chris Miller), paint supervisor: Luma Pictures / roto supervisor: Luma Pictures, paint artist: Luma Pictures (as Prin Nimminnitya) / roto artist: Luma Pictures (as Prin Nimminnitya), digital production manager: Luma Pictures, animator: Luma Pictures (as Marcos D. Romero), lead compositor: Pacific Title & Art Studio, concept artist: Luma Pictures (as Loc 'E338' Zimmermann), visual effects head of production: BOT VFX (uncredited), digital compositor: Luma Pictures (uncredited), model artist: Luma Pictures (uncredited) / texture artist: Luma Pictures (uncredited), director of business relations: Luma Pictures (uncredited), pipeline technical director: Luma Pictures (uncredited), business relations associate: Luma Pictures (uncredited), vfx executive producer: BOT VFX (uncredited) / visual effects producer: BOT VFX (uncredited), digital artist: Luma Pictures (uncredited), visual effects coordinator: Luma Pictures (uncredited), production and technical support: BOT VFX (uncredited), roto/prep supervisor: BOT VFX (uncredited), matte painter: Luma Pictures (uncredited), character technical director supervisor: Luma Pictures (uncredited), stunt double: Bob Taylor (as Eric La Rocca Mainade), edge head technician (as Darrick C. Akey), operator: Edge crane (as Michael Barnett), camera operator: "a" camera (as Roger A. Deakins), operator: Libra head (as Michael Henry Howell), operator: Libra head (as Kenny J. Rivenbark), director of photography: Flying Cam (uncredited), digital intermediate assistant producer (as Lesley Nicolucci), digital intermediate assistant producer (uncredited), location construction medic (as Joshua Dinsmore), location construction medic (as Samuel L. Gable), assistant location manager (as David R. Latham), musician: cristal baschet / musician: ondes martenot, musician: electronics / musician: guitar / musician: percussion / musician: pipe organ, musician: cello / musician: double bass / musician: electronics / musician: guitar, picture car coordinator (as Stephen E. Austin), driver: Jake Gyllenhaal (as Sean E. Marshall), assistant: Mr. Johnson / assistant: Mr. Kosove, first assistant chef: Mario's Catering (as Manuel De La Torre), general counsel: head of business affairs, detective consultant (as Jaime Fitzsimons) / police consultant (as Jaime Fitzsimons), set production assistant (as Jacob Garrison), senior vice president: legal & business affairs (as Jeannette Hill-Yonis), production office coordinator (as Heath M. Howard), set production assistant (as Jason Scott), production controller (as Michael 'Scotty' Scott), production legal provider (as Eric Spiegelman), chef assistant: Mario's Catering (as Jose Trujillo), assistant: Ms. Davis (as Jessica A. Watson), additional production assistant (uncredited), special consultant: end credits (uncredited), set production assistant: second unit (uncredited), completion bond representative (uncredited), forensic technical consultant (uncredited), basecamp production assistant: second unit (uncredited) / production assistant (uncredited), global director of motion picture logistics: Altour Travel (uncredited), production assistant: drone unit (uncredited), additional set production assistant (uncredited), production finance controller (uncredited). Instead, it gives you a pile of puzzle pieces. One interesting thing Ive noticed is that usually the highest quality movies find a way to distill their themes or narrative in the opening shot/scene. Bob somehow escaped, but the memories kept him from telling the police. What if he was like the sex offender priest, who thought no one would believe him if he spoke out, so the priest thought that only HE could stop Hollys husband the way that he did! Mississippi Department of Corrections - MS The doomsday preparation stuff does come back, kind of, with the whistle? To the point where it becomes undeniable that one theme of Us is the cultural state of America. Its a really great movie. Taylor remembered the snakes, and it was Hollys husband who had the obsession, so it makes sense that we dont see them again in the film at Hollys house. I want to watch the film again. Perhaps it was intended to reflect his personality, peaceable in normal situations, but with a killer instinct ready to take over when pushed by circumstances. Which can work for some, but not for everyone. Makes people lose their faith.. in public-policy analysis, UNC-Chapel Hill; master's of divinity . Alex and Keller will probably go to jail. And seems to have no one to talk to about what happened. But the only performance I really love is Jakes. Staring at suspect: Just because Loki has no unsolved cases doesnt mean everything he does is perfect. Type of Villain Diego. Lets get some answers. Alex spends most nights sleeping in the RV and does not have many things. [SPOILERS] Question about Prisoners : r/movies - reddit Loki saw Anna wearing the whistle at the hospital so he asked Grace if she found it, but Grace told him that Anna kept insisting that Joy helped her finding the whistle before they were kidnapped but Grace thought she was just confused so she bought her a new one. Unbeknownst to him, Joy and Anna are in another room and Joy sees him/hears him. But the same casual way he decided to choke the dog, he probably decided to bring the girls back to Holly. Or in the movie Black Swan, a theme is duality, so we often see the main character, Nina, reflected in mirrors or windows. By leaving that choice in our hands, the film becomes a moment of reflection, of confrontation. Prisoners - MoviePooper Thats what Joys remembering. The priest trapping Mr. Jones in the basement to die. I expect to be returning to this site again. moment. And this guy being a carpenter, someone who turns living trees into objects. I am from a complex family, nothing like what the film portrays but still some issues and I thank my last lucky star, Itsweird. (written by) Cast (in credits order) verified as complete Produced by Music by Jhann Jhannsson Cinematography by Roger Deakins . She has documented her whole story in a book named "Holly's Hell - My Long Journey Home" with the hopes of one day sharing it with others. The way they said it, sounded like a death notification to me. I loved the movie and really appreciate you breaking it down like that. Investigators from the Texas Attorney General's office walked into Holly's workplace on Tuesday and. So the answer to the question of Did Alex actually take Anna and Joy? is yes. The girls went to Annas home to find her whistle. I must say, I stumbled on to your site because of Prisoners but I really like what youre doing here as a whole! We see from your examples (Alex telling Keller his girls cried after being interrogated, and his torture of the dog) that the abuse he has suffered has caused him to become capable of abuse himself. Glad you liked the movie! How? Compare this to other crime thrillers like Silence of the Lambs or Seven or Girl With the Dragon Tattoo. Even with her husband gone, Holly doesn't stop and abducts Joy Birch and Anna Dover. I think we see 4-5 then the father. If someone would have put 2 and 2 together they could have solved it way sooner. Glad that came through for you! Alex succumbs to Kellers torture and mentions a maze, so Keller goes to Hollys house to see if she will reveal something about a maze. Kind of like when he lifts the dog. Within hours of her disappearance, police launch a massive search and issue an "Amber Alert," a. Despite her knowing all this, remembering all of this, what does she express? So are such small things as duct tape over someones mouth. Political party: Democrat. How David is very Christian/Jewish/Biblical while Loki is very Norse. While both of them wanted their revenge on god, Holly appeared to be a remorseless but practical vamp. Its complicated and not effective. Im also a bit confused about it. Ive got something to add: The use of the maze not not only serves as a representation of the cognitive dissonance of those abused or references the form of the information as it is laid out; it is also a cyclical device to show the nature of violence (as Kassovitz said, la Haine attire la Haine, or hate breeds hate). Additionally, this would explain the necklace. Loki will find Keller and Keller will be rescued by someone else and face that new realization that he could never have been a self sufficient island unto himself and his family. That says a lot about his mental state, the degree of Stockholm Syndrome hes experiencing. He was a fundamentalist, right? Man, I didnt even think about the carpenter thing. Theres tension as Loki hears the whistle but dismisses it, hears it again, but dismisses it again, before hearing it another time. Alias The album finishes with the very first line from the first song: So I was takin a walk the other day Its a line that begins a situation where Kendrick gets shot and killed. The girls would have died if Alex was home. Alex drives his RV to the house he had been abducted from in 1987, the home of his actual parents. Prisoners/Best scene/Denis Villeneuve/Melissa Leo/Holly Jones/Hugh Whatever segment of their brain that allowed them to not think about his disappearance their entire living day cannot ever be altered or returned. Dover seemed like a portmanteau of dove (peace) and lover. But sometimes, by shear grace, all the good and bad complications of what people do and think come together to form a hope-filled outcome. Details. Dogs: Holly said initially that she kept the girls in the hole while the police were around. Alabama woman sentenced to nearly 100 years on sodomy and bestiality The book would lack meaning because it lacked any and all context. He equally needs the cold and frosty weather because hes shot and maybe this will keep him alive a little longer (dont know, I am not a doctor) or keep the drug from effectively knocking him out. The priest is a registered sex offender, but how should he stop a child killer? Otherwise, you should close this page and view another page. Ty Chris. Her character is the embodiment of the spiritual crisis the Joneses hope to enact. Joy and Anna see the RV while on a walk with their siblings, Ralph and Eliza. Meanwhile, Bob appears as a new suspect in the case. And just to put a bow on it, when Grace brings Anna to see Loki, a similar silence occurs. That would have cinched the mystery early on. Prisoners Ending Explained (In Detail) - screenrant.com Wow, that was so helpful. he was there he visited Hollys home before he realized she was the kidnapper he said he was there to apologize for scaring off Alex and he came in and they talked but he left when he saw the paper saying that Bob killer himself. We only know that from Kellers dream, right? He was subsequently killed by the priest, who threw the body into the church's basement. Its always really nice to have that experience where you grow into appreciating a movie. Im usually pretty pedantic about things like this. Hardcover. There is a scene at the end of the film when Loki saves the little girl and the culprit shoots him, injuring him, then his blood flow into his eye. These repeating elements, and a few others, add up. Prisoners (2013) Ending Explained - Why do the Jones couple abduct the Alex Jones is Paul Sandow's older brother; Crimes & Criminals; Canon-Typical Violence; Implied/Referenced Sexual Assault; Alex Is A Good Brother; Alex & Loki have an unlikely partnership . It is mentioned, in the scene discussing the FBI agents book in Taylors house, that Taylor was abducted as a child but escaped after three weeks. And while Alex may have initially had innocent intentions with Anna and Joy, to pretend he was a child again, free from the burden of his theft, he had to have known bringing them back to Holly wouldnt end well. But at the start of the song, theres an intro that concludes with, We gon put it in reverse. Then near the end of the song, Kendrick raps, Pay attention, that one decision, changed both of they lives/One curse at a time/Reverse the manifest and good karmaBecause if Anthony killed Ducky, Top Dawg could be serving life/While I grew up without a father and die in a gunfight. Theres a gunshot and the sound of audio reversing with lyrics from earlier tracks playing backwards. Because Holly and her husband seemed to be active, external types, they dont internalize their pain, but externalize it! Prisoners (2013) - Full Cast & Crew - IMDb Avatar is kind of similar. Theres the world within a book shes reading that was written by her ex (Jake Gyllenhaal, funny enough). The exact opposite of what you would expect him to do based on what you know about his religion. We (and Keller) struggle to understand whats going through Alexs mind. Who was he waiting for? Im only 13 minutes in right now, but it is interesting! (if that was what she was doing) And why did she do it so slowly? It is frustrating that we dont get some more closure though. In Joys flashback theres a note saying to complete all the mazes in the book. The screenwriter, Aaron Guzikowski, did an interview with Buzzfeed and just straight up said: Oddly enough, thats how it was in the script when it was bought. The other maze to be found would be that; Holly drugs her victims with a concoction that may have LSD or similarthe fbi book refers to this and she does as well, when talking to and then forcing Keller to drink. Yeah, Regrading Alex, I guess theres still a lot thats up in the air. But, like the title, things arent always so simple. You did an amazing job! The Joneses were unhinged serial killers. OF COURSE! document.getElementById( "ak_js_3" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. I thought that was a major clue about the protagonist Keller Dover but at the end of the movie it seems to be a complete coincidence. Full Name I thought it was. Alex invited them into the van. I believe they say that Alex often drove the van and looked at his old house? Joy and Anna attempt to escape, but only Joy is successful. Hi Chris TORONTO - Police in Toronto on Friday arrested a 35-year-old man and charged him in connection with the killing of 10-year-old Holly Jones. Alex knows where the children are, but if he wants his Aunt in jail, and therefore stopped for good, he cant tellso its complicated. The central story of Prisoners revolves around the investigation of two missing girls, Anna and Joy, led by Detective Loki. Take revenge on God for killing her son by kidnapping other people's children (partially succeeded).Kill Loki and any other interfering witnesses (failed). But its also a clue from the filmmaker to treat the movie as a maze. What a brilliant dissection of it all. I cant remember how much time passes in the movie. Did anyone watch the movie? Its pretty well-known that the victims of abuse are prone to abusing others. But on the way back they saw the van and decided to play on it since their older siblings werent there to tell them no. Prisoners (2013) - Plot - IMDb Someone who seems like the kidnapper but isnt the killer broke into both our homes and took our kids clothes. Especially after Loki pretty much blew off Graces report about someone coming into their house.
